According to a recent Better Dwelling article, Canadian interest rates are surging higher, creating a significant hurdle for real estate prices. Last week, former Bank of Canada (BoC) Deputy Governor, Paul Beaudry, made a thought-provoking statement on the relationship between home prices and current interest rates. In this blog, we’ll explore this intriguing perspective and its implications for the Canadian real estate market.
Canadian Interest Rates and Home Prices
Former BoC Deputy Governor Paul Beaudry’s statement on Bloomberg brought to light a critical issue – Canadian interest rates are currently too high to support home prices at their current levels. This observation raises a fundamental question: Should home prices come down, or do interest rates need to decrease? The math suggests that both can’t coexist in the current market reality.
Interpreting Beaudry’s Statement
The initial reaction in the industry, as well as in Bloomberg’s reporting, was to pair Beaudry’s statement with the notion that higher interest rates are straining homeowners’ finances. While this interpretation seems straightforward, it’s not the primary point Beaudry was making. In his interview, Beaudry emphasizes that home prices are too expensive for the current interest rates. He suggests that if rates were to fall to pre-COVID levels, the current prices and tight rental market would make more sense. This perspective aligns with his previous speech on interest rates and home prices in 2021.
The BoC’s Perspective on Low Interest Rates
In 2021, Beaudry challenged the traditional narrative that lower interest rates reduce household interest costs and stimulate housing demand. He revealed a significant miscalculation in this belief. Beaudry explained that over the past two decades, the long-term decline in interest rates hadn’t lowered the debt servicing costs of Canadian households. Lower interest rates led many households to borrow more, offsetting any potential savings. As a result, the capacity to borrow expanded, but savings remained elusive.
Moreover, the lowered interest rates and increased borrowing didn’t translate into reduced housing prices. Instead, they contributed to higher house prices due to the fairly inelastic housing supply. This situation left Canada with high debt levels and elevated house prices, while debt servicing ratios remained relatively constant.
Additionally, cheaper money led to more investment in housing. Investors seized opportunities for quick gains, leading to the displacement of end-users in existing home sales. This shift toward investor ownership raised concerns about affordability and accessibility for homebuyers.
The Unsustainable Nature of Asset Values
Central bankers are increasingly voicing concerns about the sustainability of asset values at their current levels. The perspective on affordability depends on whether you’re a homeowner or someone looking to enter the housing market. From an objective standpoint, it’s evident that low interest rates have eroded affordability for decades, and lowering them may only exacerbate the issue. The Canadian real estate market has yet to adjust to the impact of higher rates, as speculators continue to rely on credit cheaper than inflation.
In conclusion, Beaudry’s observations shed light on the complex relationship between interest rates and home prices in the Canadian real estate market. It’s a reminder that the market’s dynamics are influenced by various factors, and the interplay between interest rates and home prices is a critical one.
The impact of rising interest rates in Canada has significant implications for both home buyers and home sellers:
Home Buyers:
- Higher interest rates lead to increased borrowing costs, potentially reducing the affordability of homes.
- Buyers may face more limited purchasing power and might need to reconsider their budget or property expectations.
- The competition for homes may ease slightly as some buyers become more cautious due to higher financing costs.
Home Sellers:
- Sellers may experience a slowing of demand and potentially longer time on the market as higher rates reduce the pool of qualified buyers.
- Prices could stabilize or experience slower growth, particularly in regions with highly inflated values.
- Flexibility and adaptability in pricing and marketing strategies become crucial for sellers to navigate evolving market conditions.
Real Estate Market:
- The real estate market may witness a shift towards more balanced conditions as the impact of rising rates tempers demand.
- Increased affordability challenges could result in a more gradual price appreciation.
- Market dynamics and the balance between buyers and sellers may vary by region and local economic conditions.
Rising interest rates can reshape the dynamics of the Canadian real estate market, affecting the affordability and decision-making of home buyers and the selling strategies of sellers. Market conditions are expected to evolve, influenced by the interplay between interest rates and housing demand.
Curious about our local market conditions? Call us – we love to hear from you! 604.230.9339